Skip to main content

Doping Powers New Thermoelectric Material

Adding sodium produces material that is most efficient at converting heat to electricity
  • Material provides a path for putting industrial waste heat to work
  • Potential applications in automobile industry, coal- and gas-fired power plants
  • Researchers now have ‘a few useful knobs to turn’ in developing thermoelectrics

EVANSTON, Ill. --- In the production of power, nearly two-thirds of energy input from fossil fuels is lost as waste heat. Industry is hungry for materials that can convert this heat to useful electricity, but a good thermoelectric material is hard to find.

Increasing the efficiency of thermoelectric materials is essential if they are to be used commercially. Northwestern University researchers now report that doping tin selenide with sodium boosts its performance as a thermoelectric material, pushing it toward usefulness. The doped material produces a significantly greater amount of electricity than the undoped material, given the same amount of heat input. 

Details of the sodium-doped tin selenide -- the most efficient thermoelectric material to date at producing electricity from waste heat -- were published Nov. 26 by the journal Science.

The Northwestern development could lead to new thermoelectric devices with potential applications in the automobile industry, glass- and brick-making factories, refineries, coal- and gas-fired power plants, and places where large combustion engines operate continuously (such as in large ships and tankers).

Most semiconducting materials, such as silicon, have only one conduction band to work with for doping, but tin selenide is unusual and has multiple bands; the researchers took advantage of these bands. They showed they could use sodium to access these channels and send electrons quickly through the material, driving up the heat conversion efficiency.

“The secret to our material is that multiband doping produces enhanced electrical properties,” said Mercouri G. Kanatzidis, an inorganic chemist who led the multidisciplinary team. “By doping multiple bands, we are able to multiply the positive effect. To increase the efficiency, we need the electrons to be as mobile as possible. Tin selenide provides us with a superhighway -- it has at least four fast-moving lanes for hole carriers instead of one congested lane.”

Kanatzidis, a Charles E. and Emma H. Morrison Professor of Chemistry in the Weinberg College of Arts and Sciences, is a world leader in thermoelectric materials research. He is a corresponding author of the paper.

To produce a voltage, a good thermoelectric material needs to maintain a hot side -- where the waste heat is, for example -- while the other side remains cool. (A voltage can be harvested as power.) Less than two years ago, Kanatzidis and his team, with postdoctoral fellow Lidong Zhao as protagonist, identified tin selenide as a surprisingly good thermoelectric material; it is a poor conductor of heat (much like wood) -- a desirable property for a thermoelectric -- while maintaining good electrical conductivity.

Kanatzidis’ colleague Christopher M. Wolverton, a computational theorist, calculated the electronic structure of tin selenide. He found the electrical properties could be improved by adding a doping material.

“Tin selenide is very unusual, not only because of its exceedingly low thermal conductivity, but also because it has many conduction lanes,” said Wolverton, a senior author of the paper and professor of materials science and engineering in the McCormick School of Engineering and Applied Science. “Our calculations said if the material could be doped, its thermal power and electrical conductivity would increase. But we didn’t know what to use as a dopant.”

Sodium was the first dopant the researchers tried, and it produced the results they were looking for. “Chris’ computations opened our eyes to doping,” Kanatzidis said. He and Zhao successfully grew crystals of the new doped material. 

The researchers also were pleased to see that adding sodium did not affect the already very low thermal conductivity of the material. It stayed low, so the heat stays on one side of the thermoelectric material. Electrons like to be in a low-energy state, so they move from the hot (high-energy) side to the cool side. The hot side becomes positive, and the cool side becomes negative, creating a voltage.

“Previously, there was no obvious path for finding improved thermoelectrics,” Wolverton said. “Now we have discovered a few useful knobs to turn as we develop new materials.”

The efficiency of waste heat conversion in thermoelectrics is reflected by its “figure of merit,” called ZT. In April 2014, the researchers reported that tin selenide exhibits a ZT of 2.6 at around 650 degrees Celsius. That was the highest ZT to date -- a world record. But the undoped material produced that record-high ZT only at that temperature. (There is a ZT for every temperature.)

The new doped material produces high ZTs across a broad temperature range, from room temperature to 500 degrees Celsius. Thus, the average ZT of the doped material is much higher, resulting in higher conversion efficiency. 

“Now we have record-high ZTs across a broad range of temperatures,” Kanatzidis said. “The larger the temperature difference in a thermoelectric device, the greater the efficiency.”

The research was supported, in part, by the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) Office of Science Basic Energy Sciences under grant DE-SC0014520.  

The paper is titled “Ultra-high power factor and thermoelectric performance in hole doped single crystal SnSe.” Zhao, who now is a professor at Beihang University in Beijing, is the paper’s first author.

In addition to Kanatzidis, Wolverton and Zhao, other authors of the paper are Gangjian Tan, Shiqiang Hao, Vinayak P. Dravid and G. Jeffrey Snyder, of Northwestern University; Jiaqing He of the South University of Science and Technology of China; Yanling Pei, Shengkai Gong and Huibin Xu, of Beihang University; Hang Chi and Ctirad Uher of the University of Michigan; and Heng Wang, of the California Institute of Technology.